Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
The meeting was online, of course, and Catherine Cooke welcomed us from her flat in South London.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
The stories in "The Case-Book" show notable differences from their predecessors. Two are told by Holmes himself, and two are written in the third person.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
The "Case-Book" stories are a mixed bunch, though, and the best are as good as any in the canon.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Our first speaker is Peggy Perdue, addressing us from her home in Toronto, 3,500 miles away.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Peggy Perdue is the Librarian in charge of the Special Collections at Toronto Public Library — which include the world-famous Arthur Conan Doyle Collection.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Peggy's talk is called, "Dr Watson’s Genre Play: Elements of Science Fiction, Horror and Fantasy in The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes".
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Fed up with always having to portray himself as playing second fiddle, Watson used the stories in "The Case-Book" to show what he could do as a writer of weird fiction.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
"The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes" is full of "things that go bump in the night". Perhaps Watson wanted to write a sensational novel. If he did, it may still be out there somewhere...
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Peggy Perdue's theory about "The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes" certainly makes one think!
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Our next speaker is Alistair Duncan, to tell us about "The Case of the Casebook".
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Alistair Duncan (no, that isn't actually his home) considers the reason why Conan Doyle wrote these twelve very diverse stories.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
The first of the "Case-Book" stories to be written was “The Mazarin Stone”, which uses the plot of Conan Doyle's unsuccessful play "The Crown Diamond".
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
The editor of "The Strand Magazine" wanted more Sherlock Holmes stories. Perhaps he was encouraged by the popular films starring Eille Norwood as Holmes.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Conan Doyle's main reason for writing the "Case-Book" stories was to help finance his spiritualist crusade. Even so, the best are as good as any in the Holmesian canon.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Our first speaker, Peggy Perdue, played the Game, attributing the stories in "The Case-Book" to John H. Watson. Our second, Alistair Duncan, accepted the authorship of Arthur Conan Doyle.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
What approach will our third speaker, Paul Thomas Miller, take?
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Paul Thomas Miller, founder of The Shingle of Southsea and Doyle's Rotary Coffin, speaks to us from the Sherloft, the attic room in his Portsmouth home.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
"The Secret Message in 'The Blanched Soldier'" - discovered by Paul Thomas Miller - is a remarkable one indeed.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
In this curious tale, one of only two written by Sherlock Holmes himself, Paul Thomas Miller has found an astonishing prophecy...
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Bear in mind that S is the 19th letter of the alphabet, and see if you can follow Paul Thomas Miller's ingenious reasoning.
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Yes, 95 years ago, if Paul Thomas Miller's deductions are correct, Sherlock Holmes predicted the Covid-19 pandemic!
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
The motto of Doyle's Rotary Coffin is "No Holmes Barred - Especially Dreadful Holmes, Bizarre Holmes and Sacrilegious Holmes." Today's talk falls under the heading of "Bizarre Holmes" (and why not!).
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Points from the floor include Auberon Redfearn's observation that "The Case-Book" contains such classic lines as "Come at once if convenient. If inconvenient come all the same..."
Sherlock Holmes Society of London:
Thanks to Peggy Perdue, Alistair Duncan & Paul Thomas Miller for their outstanding talks, to Catherine Cooke for chairing the meeting, and to Jane Arnold-Forster for her technical wizardry!